Give Culver's Burgers 10x The Flavor With One Simple Ordering Request
We're no strangers to hacking the (extensive) Culver's bill of fare — remember the time that we shared how to make poutine with a few canon menu items? — but what might just be our favorite trick at the home of the ButterBurger involves nothing more than a side of Wisconsin cheese sauce. We saw a TikTok reel in which a Culver's fan went through the drive-thru and asked for a jumbo side order of melty cheese. After conferring with management, the employee sold her a soup-cup tub. Once she'd received her food and pulled over, the gleeful TikToker opened her cheese up and dipped her burger, one bite at a time.
Burgers adorned with molten cheese are nothing new in American's fast food and fast casual landscape. This past year, Applebee's reintroduced its "O-M-Cheese Burger," which is served cut in half and dipped in a skillet with queso, for instance. Culver's doesn't currently offer a burger with melted cheese — its cheeseburgers come with sliced cheese — but the TikToker wondered whether a grassroots campaign might inspire the chain to put one on menus.
This isn't a trick for anyone who fears either double-dipping or steep upcharges. Culver's doesn't feature a vat of cheese sauce on its regular menu. At a West Florida location we checked on, a regular (tiny) size of cheese like one might enjoy with fries or pretzel bites was selling for $1.19. We get the distinct impression that your mileage may vary by franchise operator when it comes to the pricing of multiple cheesy servings needed for this drippy dipping burger. Culver's may offer better value than Five Guy's, but that cheese sauce requires a lot of cheddar ... by which we mean cash!
What makes Culver's cheese sauce worth the upcharge?
On one hand, we kinda get it. Dipping food in cheese sauce is practically a national pastime — we love nachos with molten cheese, for instance, but that also goes for chili fries and baked potatoes at Wendy's. Is Culver's cheese sauce really that special? Actually, it just might be: true to the chain's Midwest roots, the sauce is made with real Wisconsin sharp cheddar cheese and authentic dairy. Some dupe recipes we've found online seem to indicate that the sauce is nothing more than a roux-based cheese sauce, which would mean that the quality of the cheese is the superstar factor. On its own website, Culver's encourages pouring cheese over burgers, as well as mashed potatoes or fries.
On Reddit, an enthusiastic discussion was waged over whether Culver's might consider selling consumers a whole food service bag of the beloved cheese. Some commenters reported using the cheese in their everyday cooking and eating. "I use it for everything!" the OP reported. "I mix it in with my rice and beans, make homemade nachos, use it as a dip for bread, etc." We feel that these fans of the Culver's cheese sauce would wholly approve of ordering the cheese in bulk to dip burgers into!
Speaking of those ButterBurgers, we really can't think of a bad way to augment your handheld with cheese. Maybe go easy on the toppings (like LTO), so that they don't slip-slide into your cheese bath? We previously discussed transforming Culver's burgers by swapping the bun for sourdough bread, and we think a sourdough burger would taste just delish in some Wisconsin cheese!